Kingdom- book review

I’m a big fan of historical novels and of Robyn Young, one of the top writers in this genre who wrote a great trilogy about the Templars and the Crusades. Kingdom is the final book in Young’s trilogy about Scottish nobleman Robert Bruce and his fight to become the king and win independence from the English.

While Robert Bruce is famous not just for his victories and ascension to Scotland’s throne, he is also well-known for his many failures against the English. In Kingdom, newly-crowned Bruce has embarked on another uprising against the English but suffers defeat after defeat, forcing him to retreat to the isles off Western Scotland and putting him into a precarious position. Meanwhile, the fearsome but ailing elderly English king Edward I, or Longshanks, having seen off William Wallace (the hero in the 1995 epic movie Braveheart) by capturing, hanging and quartering him, mounts one final campaign to eradicate Bruce and bring Scotland into England’s grasp once and for all. The English are beset by bickering nobles and a gay scandal involving the prince (people will have also seen this played out in Braveheart). The story concludes with the Battle of Bannockburn where Robert Bruce fulfills his destiny.

The novel does not include the popular legend attributed to Bruce of how after suffering his seventh defeat, he was in a cave and saw a spider trying to spin a web, only to fail again and again until it succeeded on its eight try, which then inspired Bruce to mount one final battle against the English which he won. Instead, Young replaces this with the inclusion of a female wizard and her “web of destiny” for Bruce. In addition, there is also a fictional plot about the English king Edward I exploiting the legend of King Arthur and a prophecy to try to “unite” Britain, including creating his own version of the Knights of the Round Table to induce elite British knights to carry out Edward’s vision.

Despite being full of battles and sieges, the novel relies less on action than on recreating the historical drama, intrigue and urgency of Bruce’s desperate campaign, whilst including a strong element of myths like the wizard and the prophecy. Bruce encounters so many setbacks and defeats, including the destruction of his army in an ambush and the capture of his brothers and family by the English, whilst continuously being pursued by superior forces that at times it seems that he will never win. The doggedness of Bruce in attempting to achieve victory is almost as big a part of the story as the fighting.

As this is the third novel of the trilogy, Young uses lengthy recollections by the characters to bring newer readers up to date on events, which proves very useful and not distracting.

Kingdom proves to be a stirring story that blends history, drama and action to create a deeply satisfying read and a fitting conclusion.


4 thoughts on “Kingdom- book review

  1. For as infatuated as I can be with Scotland (Ireland and Wales as well), I know very little about their history except for some of the more glamorous tales you’ve mentioned here (Braveheart being the biggest). Historical fiction is one of the guilty pleasures that can steal away my time (Irving Stone my favorite of such writers). I will have to check Kingdom….it sounds fascinating. Thank you for the review.


    1. That’s cool you’re a fan of historical fiction as well. I’ve heard of Irving Stone. I’ll try to check out his books in future. I know little about Scotland but Kingdom and the two books (I read the second one) before that helped a bit.


      1. When I was a kid, I read “Greek Treasure” by Irving Stone and I think that instilled a sense of travel and adventure for me. “The Agony & Ecstasy” and “Lust for Life” then followed, an amazing writer. I hope you do check out his books and let me know. They impacted me quite a bit. Cheers to a great New Year! 猴年大吉!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.